Skip to main content
RealCostIQ

HVAC · cost comparison

Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace in 2026: Installed Cost and Cost to Run

The math behind the choice: what each system costs to install, what a million BTU of heat costs from gas and from electricity at current EIA prices, and where a heat pump stops winning.

RealCostIQUpdated October 21, 202624 min readRenovation & Repair · United States

The short answer

At the national average prices the U.S. Energy Information Administration (EIA) published for 2025 gas and July 2026 electricity, a 95% AFUE gas furnace delivers heat for about $15.59 per million BTU. A heat pump rated HSPF2 8.1 costs about $22.60. One running at a seasonal COP of 3 costs about $17.89. Installed, the heat pump also replaces your air conditioner.

Run your numbers
Heat Pump vs Gas Furnace in 2026: Installed Cost and Cost to Run. Bar chart of heating cost per million BTU delivered at EIA national average prices: a 95% gas furnace is cheapest at $15.59, heat pumps run $15.33 to $23.47 depending on efficiency, and electric resistance costs $53.66.

Choosing between a heat pump and a furnace is really two separate questions. The first is what it costs to buy and install. A heat pump does the job of a furnace and an air conditioner (AC). So compare it with a furnace plus an AC, not a furnace alone. The second is what a unit of heat costs to make. That depends mostly on the ratio of your electricity price to your gas price. This post does both with the math shown, so you can use your own utility rates.

This post does not repeat the price tables or the repair-versus-replace decision from our other pages. For installed-cost ranges by system and size, use the HVAC installation cost calculator. HVAC stands for heating, ventilation and air conditioning. You can also use the furnace and AC replacement cost calculator. Maybe your current system still runs, and you are asking whether to replace it at all. That is a separate repair-or-replace decision, and this post does not cover it. What follows is the head-to-head: heat pump against gas furnace, on installed cost and on running cost.

Installed cost: a heat pump replaces two machines

The RealCostIQ calculators price replacement jobs from a single national table. The table cites Angi's 2026 HVAC replacement cost guide (updated August 3, 2026, read by us on 2026-09-24). The replacement calculators and the repair-or-replace guide use the same table, so the figures below match those pages. These are national installed ranges. Your metro area, house size, ductwork condition and brand move them.

Installed replacement cost by system, national range (RealCostIQ calculator table, sourced to Angi 2026)
What you installInstalled rangeWhat it covers
Gas furnace only$3,800–$10,000Heating only. You still own a separate AC.
Central AC only$3,900–$7,900Cooling only. You still own a separate furnace.
Furnace + AC together$5,000–$12,500Heating and cooling, two outdoor/indoor systems.
Heat pump$4,200–$7,600Heating and cooling from one system.

Source: the RealCostIQ HVAC repair-or-replace and furnace-AC replacement calculators, which cite Angi, "How Much Does HVAC Replacement Cost? [2026 Data]" (updated Aug 3, 2026). Ranges are national; new ductwork can push a full system toward roughly $22,000 per the same source. These are ranges, not quotes.

Two-column comparison of national installed costs: a heat pump runs $4,200 to $7,600 and heats and cools from one system, while a gas furnace plus central AC runs $5,000 to $12,500 for two systems.
A heat pump heats and cools, so compare it with a furnace plus an AC when both are due. These are national ranges, not quotes.

Read the table as a purchase decision, not a shopping list. Say the furnace is dying and the AC is also near the end of its life. Then you are comparing a heat pump at $4,200–$7,600 with a furnace-plus-AC job at $5,000–$12,500. Say the AC is fine and only the furnace failed. Then you are comparing a heat pump against a $3,800–$10,000 furnace. In that case the heat pump has to justify itself on running cost and on the AC you would otherwise keep. The range for a furnace is wide because a basic 80% unit and a modulating 98% condensing unit (a high-efficiency model that adjusts its output) are very different products. We come back to this under AFUE below.

What ductless mini-splits cost

A ductless system is the heat pump option for homes with no ducts, additions, and rooms the furnace never heated well. Ducts are the tubes that carry warm or cool air through the house. The mini-split installation cost calculator prices a heat-pump mini-split as a condenser, indoor head units and labor. At mid-range brand and standard install difficulty, its model produces the estimates below. They are RealCostIQ calculator estimates built from component bands, not quotes. They exclude any electrical work beyond what the labor band assumes.

Mini-split heat pump installed estimate, mid-range brand (RealCostIQ calculator model)
ConfigurationEstimated range
1 zone, 12,000 BTU/h$1,250–$2,500
2 zones, 12,000 BTU/h each$2,200–$4,300
3 zones, 12,000 BTU/h each$3,150–$6,000
4 zones, 18,000 BTU/h each$5,000–$9,500

Estimated by the RealCostIQ mini-split installation calculator as outdoor unit + indoor heads + labor for a heat-pump (not cooling-only) system at mid-range brand. A difficult install multiplies the labor line by 1.3; a premium brand multiplies equipment by 1.3. Treat the low end as a basic, easy install and get several local quotes.

A mini-split is not automatically the cheaper heat pump. Per zone the equipment is cheaper. But covering a whole house takes several heads, and at four zones the total overlaps with or exceeds the ducted heat pump range in the first table. A zone is one area with its own indoor unit. The mini-split wins where ducts do not exist or leak badly, or where only part of the house needs conditioning. If the ducts exist and are sound, a ducted heat pump usually reuses them. New or repaired ducts can change that answer. Angi's figure above notes that new ductwork can push a full system toward roughly $22,000.

What dual-fuel adds

A dual-fuel system pairs an electric heat pump with a gas furnace and switches between them. You pay for both pieces of equipment plus the controls. In the RealCostIQ HVAC installation cost calculator, the dual-fuel system type has a higher equipment line and a higher labor line than a heat pump alone. That is the structural reason it costs more up front. You are buying a heat pump and a furnace, with one outdoor unit and one indoor coil still shared. The dual-fuel section below covers what you get for the premium.

What changed when the 25C credit ended

The federal Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit (Internal Revenue Code section 25C) covered qualifying heat pumps up to $2,000 per year. The Internal Revenue Service (IRS) states that the credit applies to property placed in service before December 31, 2025. It also states that the $2,000 annual cap applied to heat pumps, heat pump water heaters and biomass stoves or boilers. A heat pump placed in service in 2026 does not qualify. Our home energy tax credits 2026 guide tracks the status of all of the federal home-energy credits. Check it to see whether any rule has changed.

How much that matters depends on price. Use the installed range above. The maximum $2,000 credit was worth roughly 26% to 48% of a $4,200–$7,600 heat pump (2,000 divided by 7,600, and by 4,200). The credit was capped at that dollar amount, however expensive the job got. It was a meaningful discount. But it was never the main reason one system beat the other on lifetime cost. The end of the credit changes the payback timeline, not the direction of the comparison. If a heat pump was cheaper to run at your prices, it still is. The break-even point, where savings repay the extra cost, just moves out. The delay equals the lost discount divided by your annual savings.

State and utility rebates

What replaced the federal credit is a patchwork. Some states, utilities, municipal utilities and co-ops (member-owned utilities) offer rebates or low-interest financing for heat pumps. Many offer nothing. Amounts, caps, income rules and program funding change often. We do not list dollar figures here, because any figure we printed would be stale or wrong for your address. The database to use is DSIRE. The N.C. Clean Energy Technology Center at N.C. State University runs it. You can search incentives and policies by state or ZIP code. Treat it as a starting point. DSIRE does not state how often it is updated on the page we read. So confirm the current amount, and whether funds remain, on the program administrator's own page before you sign. Rebate programs are often first-come, first-served against an annual budget.

Two ordering mistakes cost people money. The first is signing a contract before checking whether the program requires pre-approval. Some do. The second is buying the lower-priced unit that misses a program's minimum efficiency or cold-climate listing requirement. Check the qualifying-equipment list first. Then choose the contractor.

Operating cost per million BTU, with the math

Gas is sold by the thousand cubic feet. Electricity is sold by the kilowatt-hour (kWh). The only fair comparison puts both in the same unit: dollars per million BTU (MMBtu) of heat delivered into the house. A BTU, or British thermal unit, is a small unit of heat energy. The conversions come from the U.S. Energy Information Administration: 1 cubic foot of natural gas is about 1,036 Btu, and 1 kWh of electricity is 3,412 Btu.

Step 1: price inputs from EIA

The summer gas figure looks absurdly high. EIA's residential price is total gas revenue divided by volume. In July, households burn little gas, but the fixed monthly customer charge stays the same. That is why we use the annual 2025 average of $15.34 for the main comparison, rather than the most recent month. The same fixed-charge effect applies to electricity, but it is smaller per unit. It also means the "marginal" gas price can be below these averages. The marginal price is what the last unit you burn in January adds. Both prices are national averages. Your own bill is what matters.

Step 2: convert both to dollars per MMBtu of fuel

  • Gas: 1 Mcf = 1,000 cubic feet x 1,036 Btu = 1.036 MMBtu. So $15.34 / 1.036 = $14.81 per MMBtu of gas burned.
  • Electricity: 1 kWh = 3,412 Btu, so 1 MMBtu = 1,000,000 / 3,412 = 293.1 kWh. At 18.31 cents per kWh, 293.1 x $0.1831 = $53.66 per MMBtu of electricity.

Electricity is about 3.6 times the price of gas per unit of energy in these two inputs (53.66 divided by 14.81). That ratio is the whole story. Straight electric resistance heating turns every kWh into heat. A baseboard heater or an electric furnace works this way. It delivers heat at $53.66 per MMBtu. A gas furnace burns cheap energy but loses some up the flue. A heat pump bridges the gap. It moves heat instead of making it, so it gets more than one unit of heat per unit of electricity. The whole comparison comes down to one question. Is the heat pump's multiplier bigger than the price ratio, after the furnace's losses are counted?

Step 3: divide by efficiency to get the cost of heat delivered

Furnace efficiency is stated as AFUE, annual fuel utilization efficiency. It is the share of the fuel's energy that becomes usable heat over a heating season. A 95% AFUE furnace turns 95% of the gas into room heat and loses 5%. Heat pump efficiency is stated as HSPF2, heating season performance factor. The U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) states it in Btu of heat per watt-hour of electricity. Divide HSPF2 by 3.412 (Btu per Wh), and you get the seasonal coefficient of performance (COP). That is the units of heat per unit of electricity.

Cost of delivered heat at EIA national average prices
SystemEfficiencyHow computed$ per MMBtu delivered
Gas furnace, 80% AFUE0.8014.81 / 0.80$18.51
Gas furnace, 95% AFUE0.9514.81 / 0.95$15.59
Electric resistanceCOP 1.053.66 / 1.0$53.66
Heat pump, HSPF2 7.8 (ENERGY STAR split-system floor)COP 2.2953.66 / (7.8 / 3.412)$23.47
Heat pump, HSPF2 8.1COP 2.3753.66 / (8.1 / 3.412)$22.60
Heat pump, HSPF2 9.0COP 2.6453.66 / (9.0 / 3.412)$20.34
Heat pump, COP 3.0 (assumed seasonal)COP 3.053.66 / 3.0$17.89
Heat pump, COP 3.5 (assumed seasonal)COP 3.553.66 / 3.5$15.33

Inputs: EIA residential gas $15.34/Mcf (2025 annual average), residential electricity 18.31 cents/kWh (July 2026), and EIA conversions of 1,036 Btu per cubic foot and 3,412 Btu per kWh. Computed by RealCostIQ; AFUE and COP values are the efficiency levels shown, not a specific product. The 7.8 HSPF2 row is the ENERGY STAR value for split-system heat pumps listed in DOE's federal purchasing guidance. COP 3.0 and 3.5 rows are illustrative assumptions, not measurements.

Bar chart of heating cost per million BTU delivered at EIA national average prices: a 95% gas furnace is cheapest at $15.59, heat pumps run $15.33 to $23.47 depending on efficiency, and electric resistance costs $53.66.
At national average prices a 95 percent furnace beats heat pumps at common HSPF2 ratings, but every heat pump is far cheaper than electric resistance heat. Your own utility prices can change the order.

Three things stand out. First, at these national averages a high-efficiency gas furnace is cheaper per unit of heat than any heat pump rated at the common HSPF2 levels. Second, the gap against an old 80% furnace is much smaller. An HSPF2 9.0 heat pump comes within about $1.83 per MMBtu of an 80% furnace, and a seasonal COP of 3 beats it. Third, no heat pump comes close to the cost of electric resistance. That is why switching from baseboard heat or an electric furnace to a heat pump is the strongest economic case for the technology. The table shows it: 22.60 is a 58% reduction from 53.66 at HSPF2 8.1.

The break-even efficiency

To match a 95% AFUE gas furnace on fuel cost, a heat pump needs a seasonal COP of 53.66 divided by 15.59, or 3.44. That is an HSPF2 of about 11.7 (3.44 x 3.412). To match an 80% furnace, it needs a COP of 53.66 divided by 18.51, or 2.90. That is about HSPF2 9.9. Those are the national-average numbers. Change the price ratio and the answer moves. At the 2024 annual electricity price of 16.48 cents, electricity costs $48.30 per MMBtu. A COP of 3.0 then delivers heat at $16.10, closer to the gas furnace. In a region with 10 cent electricity and expensive gas, a heat pump wins by a wide margin. In a region with 25 cent electricity and cheap gas, the furnace keeps winning.

Turning dollars per MMBtu into a seasonal bill

To get an annual figure, multiply by the heat your house needs. This is an illustration only. Assume a home that needs 60 MMBtu of delivered heat in a winter. That load is an assumption for the example, not a statistic. Your own load depends on climate, size and insulation. Then the seasonal heating bill would be about $935 with a 95% furnace (60 x 15.59). It would be $1,111 with an 80% furnace (60 x 18.51). It would be $1,356 with an HSPF2 8.1 heat pump (60 x 22.60). And it would be $1,073 with a heat pump at a seasonal COP of 3 (60 x 17.89). The differences are a few hundred dollars a year. That is why installed cost and the air conditioner you no longer buy often matter as much as the running cost.

To redo the math with your own bills, find the price per therm or per CCF (a hundred cubic feet) on your gas bill. A therm is 100,000 Btu, so $1.481 per therm is $14.81 per MMBtu. Also find your cents per kWh. Then use the formula in the table. Do not use the bill total divided by usage unless you are sure the fixed charges are part of the cost you would avoid. For electricity, you would not avoid them.

The break-even test for your own bills

National averages hide a wide spread. The same heat pump can lose in one state and win in the next. You can test your own house in three steps. Find your price per kWh and your price per therm on your bills. Then use this formula. The COP you need = price per kWh x 29.3 x furnace AFUE, divided by price per therm. AFUE is written as a decimal, so 95% is 0.95. If the heat pump's real seasonal COP is higher than the answer, it costs less to run than the furnace.

The 29.3 is just 1 MMBtu in kWh (293.1) divided by 10 therms per MMBtu. At the U.S. averages above, the formula gives 0.1831 x 29.31 x 0.95 / 1.481 = 3.44. That matches the break-even in the last section. Here it is for five states, from a low electricity-to-gas price ratio to a high one.

Seasonal COP a heat pump needs to match a gas furnace on fuel cost, five states
StateElectricity (cents/kWh)Gas ($/therm)Price ratioCOP needed vs 95% furnaceCOP needed vs 80% furnace
Florida15.03$2.461.81.701.43
Washington14.71$1.702.52.412.03
Massachusetts30.49$2.423.73.512.96
Pennsylvania21.72$1.454.44.173.51
Michigan23.05$1.056.46.095.13

Computed by RealCostIQ from EIA state residential prices: electricity for July 2026 (Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.6.A) and natural gas for 2025 annual (EIA, $/Mcf divided by 10.36 therms per Mcf). Price ratio is dollars per MMBtu of electricity divided by dollars per MMBtu of gas. State gas averages include fixed monthly charges, so the per-therm price you would save is lower and the real COP needed is a little higher. Mixed periods (July electricity, annual gas) match the method used above.

Bar chart of the seasonal COP needed to match a 95 percent gas furnace on fuel cost: Florida 1.70, Washington 2.41, U.S. average 3.44, Massachusetts 3.51, Pennsylvania 4.17, Michigan 6.09. Lower bars favor the heat pump.
A typical seasonal COP of 2.4 to 3 beats a 95 percent furnace only where electricity is cheap next to gas. Check your own two prices.

Read it like this. A heat pump with a seasonal COP of 3 beats a 95% furnace on fuel cost in Florida and Washington. It loses in Massachusetts, Pennsylvania and Michigan. An HSPF2 8.1 unit (COP 2.37) beats it only in Florida. Against an old 80% furnace the bar drops, and COP 3 also wins in Massachusetts at 2.96. Fuel cost is not the whole answer, because the heat pump also replaces the AC. But this test tells you which side of the line your prices fall on.

Do not use the state average as your answer. Use your own bills. Gas and electric rates vary by utility, and a few cents on either price can move the result.

HSPF2, SEER2 and AFUE, and why they are not comparable

AFUE is a ratio with a ceiling of 100%, because a furnace cannot deliver more heat than the fuel contains. HSPF2 is Btu per watt-hour. It can be well above 3.412, because a heat pump moves heat that already exists outside. So a heat pump can be more than 100% efficient in the plain-English sense, and a furnace cannot. It also means you cannot compare the two numbers directly. Divide HSPF2 by 3.412 first.

Since January 1, 2023, DOE uses a revised test procedure. Heat pumps are now rated by HSPF2, and cooling by SEER2 (seasonal energy efficiency ratio). The test changed, so do not compare an old HSPF figure to a new HSPF2 figure. ENERGY STAR is the federal energy-efficiency label. Its air-source heat pump page lists current requirements as effective January 1, 2023. It states that a heat pump can deliver up to three times as much heat energy as the electrical energy it consumes. That is the same as a COP of 3. The ENERGY STAR value for split systems, which have an indoor and an outdoor unit, is quoted in DOE's federal purchasing guidance. It is 15.2 SEER2 and 7.8 HSPF2.

Two things the label does not tell you. First, HSPF2 is a seasonal average across a standardized climate, so it blends mild and cold days. A house in a colder place, with more hours at low temperatures, will see a worse real COP than the label implies. Second, look at AFUE. ENERGY STAR notes that certified furnaces carry higher AFUE ratings and higher efficiency blower motors than standard models. It describes up to 16% better efficiency in the South and up to 18% in the North versus baseline models. It estimates annual savings of about $60 and $160 respectively. That is the size of the prize in moving from a standard furnace to a high-efficiency one: tens of dollars to low hundreds, not thousands.

Cold-climate performance: what the field studies measured

The argument against heat pumps in cold regions used to be that they stop working. The field data say it is more nuanced: modern inverter-driven units keep working well below freezing, but how much backup heat gets used depends heavily on how the system was sized and set up. Three sources we read:

  • ORNL field test, Ohio. Oak Ridge National Laboratory (ORNL) ran a field investigation of a cold-climate heat pump in an occupied Ohio home during winter 2015. The system operated down to -13°F without resistance heat. It had a measured seasonal COP of 3.16. Its tandem compressors were designed to provide 75% of rated heating capacity at -13°F. It saved more than 40% energy in the peak heating month versus the single-speed heat pump previously in that home. This is one house in one winter: a data point, not a guarantee.
  • NREL ductless study, Northeast. The National Renewable Energy Laboratory (NREL) wrote a field performance study of inverter-driven heat pumps in cold climates (August 2015). It monitored seven ductless units. It notes that the question of how cold is too cold had no clear answer. It said this uncertainty could lead to skepticism among homeowners, poor savings estimates, suboptimal equipment selection by contractors and inconsistent energy modeling. The point of the study was to measure it rather than assume.
  • NREL ducted study, Northwest and Colorado. NREL's field validation of air-source heat pumps for cold climates (Winkler and Ramaraj, May 2023) monitored 13 central variable-speed heat pumps in single-family homes in IECC climate zones 5 and 6. IECC is the International Energy Conservation Code. Most homes were in Washington and Montana, plus one near Denver. The study reports data on 12 of them. At 5 of the 11 all-electric sites it reported on, electric resistance backup heat exceeded 40% of compressor-based heating energy. At 2 of those 5, the backup heat used more energy than the compressor. One was because the system was undersized. One was because of a control or sensor fault.

Put together: a cold-climate-rated variable-speed unit can run, and run efficiently, in the low single digits and below. But in the larger NREL sample, a substantial minority of installations leaned heavily on electric resistance backup. Resistance heat costs $53.66 per MMBtu on the prices above. That is more than three times what a gas furnace costs. So a heat pump that falls back on its backup strips will not deliver the savings the label implies. The causes are not exotic. One is equipment sizing relative to the home's heating load. Another is where the thermostat and controls tell the backup to start. A third is whether the unit is a true cold-climate model.

ENERGY STAR's air-source heat pump page notes that its certification requires third-party-verified performance at low temperatures, with units tested down to 5°F. Suppose winter lows where you live go below that. Then ask the installer for the manufacturer's published capacity and COP at your design temperature, which is the cold day the system is sized for. Also ask what the backup is set to do. The single best sign of a system that behaves as advertised is a contractor who has done a heating load calculation. Sizing by square footage, or by matching the old furnace, is a worse sign.

Dual-fuel: the hedge

Dual-fuel (sometimes called hybrid) keeps the gas furnace as the backup instead of electric resistance strips. A control switches heating from the heat pump to the furnace below a chosen outdoor temperature. This temperature is called the balance point or lockout. The logic follows from the table above. The heat pump is efficient in mild weather, when the price ratio can favor it. Gas takes over when the heat pump's efficiency drops and electric resistance would be the expensive fallback. The savings come from replacing a $53.66 per MMBtu backup with a $15.59 backup.

It costs more because you buy and maintain two heating appliances, as covered above. It makes the most sense in three situations. One is a cold climate where you want a gas safety net. Another is an existing furnace that is young enough not to need replacing. The third is a home where the electrical service or the budget makes a full conversion hard. In a mild climate, it adds cost for backup you will rarely use. In a very cold one with cheap gas, the heat pump may run only in the shoulder seasons (spring and fall). In that case, ask whether the heat pump's higher cost is actually earning its keep over a furnace plus a standard AC.

Where to set the changeover is a real economic choice. A heat pump's COP falls as it gets colder. So there is an outdoor temperature at which its cost per MMBtu equals the furnace's. Your installer can compute that balance point from your two prices and the unit's capacity and COP data at various temperatures. It is a cheaper decision to make with a calculator than to leave at a factory default.

Decision table by climate

This table is qualitative guidance built from the price math and field studies above. It is not a computed ranking. It assumes a house with decent insulation. Your electricity-to-gas price ratio can overturn any row, so check it first.

Which system fits which climate (RealCostIQ guidance)
ClimateHeat pump aloneGas furnace + ACDual-fuel
Hot-humid or hot-dry (little heating)Usually the best fit. Heating hours are few, so the heat pump's efficiency penalty on gas-equivalent cost is small, and it replaces the AC.Only if you already own a working furnace.Rarely worth the added equipment.
Mixed / mild wintersStrong fit, especially if you are replacing electric resistance or an aging AC and furnace together. Compare your price ratio.Competitive when gas is much cheaper than electricity and the AC is still good.Optional hedge.
Cold (IECC zone 5 range)Works with a cold-climate-rated, correctly sized unit; the NREL sample shows backup use can be heavy when sizing or controls are wrong.Often the lowest running cost where gas is cheap.Good fit: heat pump in shoulder seasons, gas below the balance point.
Very cold (IECC zone 6 and up)Possible with cold-climate models and good insulation; ask for capacity and COP at your design temperature.Strong where gas is available and cheap.Strong fit when gas is available; the furnace carries the coldest weeks.
Any climate, no gas serviceLikely the best option versus electric resistance, propane or oil; run your own fuel prices.Not applicable.Not applicable.

Climate zones follow IECC usage in the NREL study (zones 5 and 6 are its cold-climate sites). This table is judgment, not a measured result; none of its cells is a quote or a promise of savings.

Only one unit died: replace both or one?

Say the furnace failed and the AC still works. You have two choices. Replace the furnace and keep the AC. Or install a heat pump, which does both jobs and makes the working AC redundant. On the national table, a furnace alone is $3,800 to $10,000 and a heat pump is $4,200 to $7,600. These ranges are not paired quotes, but they overlap. At the low ends the heat pump costs about $400 more (4,200 minus 3,800). At the high ends it costs about $2,400 less (7,600 minus 10,000).

The real cost of switching is the AC you retire early. Ask for two written quotes on the same day: one furnace-only and one heat pump. Subtract the furnace-only quote from the heat pump quote. That gap is what you pay to switch. Then check the COP table above. If your prices favor the heat pump, the gap is a small bet. If they do not, the gap buys you a newer cooling system and a gas bill that you may not need. In the 60 MMBtu example, a COP 3 heat pump costs about $138 a year more to run than a 95% furnace (60 x (17.89 minus 15.59)). Ask whether the gap pays that back.

If both units are near the end of life, do not split the job. Price the heat pump against furnace plus AC together ($5,000 to $12,500), as the install-cost section shows.

How to decide for your house

  1. Pull your two prices. Take gas in dollars per therm and multiply by 10 for dollars per MMBtu of fuel. Take electricity in cents per kWh and multiply by 2.931 for dollars per MMBtu. Divide the electricity figure by the gas figure and multiply by 0.95. A 95% furnace beats any heat pump whose seasonal COP is below that number, on fuel cost alone (3.44 at the national averages above).
  2. Decide what you are replacing. If the AC is also due, compare the heat pump against furnace plus AC, not furnace alone. If you are replacing electric resistance, the heat pump almost always wins.
  3. Get a load calculation, not a guess. Ask each contractor for a heating load calculation and the unit's rated capacity at your design temperature. Ask how the backup heat is controlled.
  4. Ask for the price before incentives. Then look up state and utility programs on DSIRE and the program administrators' own pages. The federal credit is gone for 2026 installs.
  5. Get at least three quotes. Compare equipment, tonnage (system size), efficiency ratings, warranty, and whether permits and electrical work are included.

Run both options through the RealCostIQ calculators as a sanity check on quotes. Use the HVAC installation cost calculator for heat pump and dual-fuel system types. Use the furnace and AC replacement cost calculator for the combined replacement. Use the mini-split installation cost calculator if the house has no usable ducts. They produce estimates. A contractor's line-item quote should land near them or explain the difference.

Run your numbers

HVAC installation cost calculator

Price a heat pump, gas furnace, or dual-fuel system by home size and efficiency.

Open the calculator

Frequently asked questions

Is a heat pump cheaper to run than a gas furnace in 2026?

It depends on your prices. At EIA's national averages (gas $15.34 per Mcf for 2025, electricity 18.31 cents per kWh for July 2026), a 95% AFUE furnace delivers heat for about $15.59 per million BTU. A heat pump rated HSPF2 8.1 delivers it for about $22.60, so the furnace is cheaper. A heat pump at a seasonal COP of 3 comes to about $17.89. Against an old 80% furnace ($18.51), it wins. Where electricity is cheap relative to gas, the heat pump wins by more.

What is the difference between HSPF2 and AFUE?

AFUE is the share of a furnace's fuel energy that becomes heat over a season. It is capped at 100%. HSPF2 is a heat pump's seasonal heat output in Btu divided by the electricity it uses in watt-hours. To compare them, divide HSPF2 by 3.412 to get the COP. Then compare the cost of delivered heat using your own gas and electricity prices, as in the table in this post.

Did the heat pump tax credit end?

Yes. The IRS says the Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit (25C) applies to property placed in service before December 31, 2025. It was capped at $2,000 per year for heat pumps. A heat pump installed in 2026 does not qualify. Our home energy tax credits 2026 guide tracks the status. State and utility rebates may still exist. Search DSIRE for your state and ZIP code.

How much does a mini split heat pump cost to install?

It depends on zones, size, brand and labor. Use the mini-split installation cost calculator to price your setup. The table in this post shows sample estimates.

Do heat pumps work below freezing?

Cold-climate models do. ORNL measured a seasonal COP of 3.16 in an Ohio home, with operation down to -13°F and no resistance heat. But NREL's cold-zone field study found backup heat above 40% of compressor-based heating energy at 5 of 11 all-electric sites. So sizing and controls matter. ENERGY STAR certification tests low-temperature performance down to 5°F.

Is dual-fuel worth the extra cost?

It can be, in cold climates where gas is available. The heat pump handles mild weather. The furnace replaces expensive electric resistance backup in the coldest weather. It costs more because you buy both systems. In a mild climate the furnace gets little use, so the extra equipment rarely pays back. Ask your installer to compute the balance-point temperature from your own prices.

Do gas fixed charges count if I keep a gas stove or water heater?

No. If you keep any gas appliance, the monthly customer charge stays on your bill either way. So it is not a cost of the heat pump. Compare only the per-therm price you would stop paying. Say the fee is $15 a month, which is an assumed figure. It is $180 a year. You save that only if you cancel gas service entirely. In that case, add it to the heat pump side. State average gas prices include the fee, so the true per-therm price you avoid is lower.

Where do I find heat pump rebates for my state?

Start with DSIRE, the database run by the N.C. Clean Energy Technology Center at N.C. State University. It searches incentives by state or ZIP code. Then confirm the amount, eligibility, equipment list and remaining funds on the utility or state program's own page before signing a contract. Rebates are often pre-approval and budget-limited.

Sources

  1. EIA — Residential Natural Gas Price, annual, U.S. and states ($/Mcf; U.S. 2025 = $15.34; state rows read 2026-10-21) — read October 21, 2026
  2. EIA — U.S. Residential Natural Gas Price, monthly (Jan 2026 $13.96; Jul 2026 $26.45; data released Sept 30, 2026) — read October 5, 2026
  3. EIA — Electric Power Monthly, Table 5.6.A (residential 18.31 cents/kWh U.S., July 2026; state rows read 2026-10-21) — read October 21, 2026
  4. EIA — Electricity Annual, average price by sector (residential 16.48 cents/kWh in 2024) — read October 5, 2026
  5. EIA — British thermal units (Btu) conversion factors (1 cubic foot gas = 1,036 Btu; 1 kWh = 3,412 Btu) — read October 5, 2026
  6. IRS — Energy Efficient Home Improvement Credit (25C end date and $2,000 heat pump cap) — read October 5, 2026
  7. DSIRE — Database of State Incentives for Renewables & Efficiency (N.C. Clean Energy Technology Center) — read October 5, 2026
  8. ENERGY STAR — Air Source Heat Pumps (requirements effective Jan 1, 2023; tested down to 5°F) — read October 5, 2026
  9. ENERGY STAR — Furnaces (AFUE, regional efficiency and savings) — read October 5, 2026
  10. DOE FEMP — Purchasing Energy-Efficient Residential Air-Source Heat Pumps (HSPF2 definition, 15.2 SEER2 / 7.8 HSPF2) — read October 5, 2026
  11. ORNL — Field investigation of an air-source cold climate heat pump (Ohio, winter 2015, down to -13°F, seasonal COP 3.16) — read October 5, 2026
  12. NREL — Field Validation of Air-Source Heat Pumps for Cold Climates (Winkler and Ramaraj, NREL/TP-5500-84745, May 2023; full report read) — read October 5, 2026
  13. NREL — Field Performance of Inverter-Driven Heat Pumps in Cold Climates (2015) — read October 5, 2026

This article explains general rules and published figures. It is not legal, tax or financial advice for your situation; rules change, so check the source and a qualified professional before you act.